15 Comments

the more I read about The Brutalist the more it seems clear I have no idea what's going on -- either in it, or any other movie

Expand full comment

can’t stop thinking about the Next Best Picture guy calling it “an immense tower of American storytelling”. A tower of storytelling? Is that an expression? Did he forget the phrase “towering achievement” while he was typing this one handed at the urinal between screenings? and now when I finally see The Brutalist I will be thinking about Clare’s review too — trying to be openhearted but the most compelling pieces on it so far have been the pans (Vadim’s in Filmmaker esp)

Expand full comment
author

exactly. empty platitudes about scope and scale. if a movie makes you talk like you've never seen a movie before / you're unable to clearly describe why you liked it maybe head back to the drawing board. i'll read vadim's review now

Expand full comment

loved Essence of Ghost btw

Expand full comment
author

randomly so good

Expand full comment

this is exactly how i too felt about Saturday Night, a movie i watched with a big coca-cola and smiling like this: :)

Expand full comment
author

it’s movie made for a freestyle machine world

Expand full comment

no exactly

Expand full comment

I want to like The Brutalist (need to see what my Joesph is up) and I cannot bring myself to read your criticism until I see it. I appreciate how hard you go when you don’t like something and am eagerly waiting to return to it.

Expand full comment
author

i can't imagine you will be thrilled by joe's turn here... crazily unpleasant thing to watch & hear

Expand full comment

This is the worst news I’ve heard since I found out Emerald Fennel’s Wuthering Heights adaptation

Expand full comment

thankfully for my ego, the things i like about the brutalist are not what you suggest the fans will like about it i just like the cinematography and adrien brody’s face lalala

Expand full comment
author

oh it was beautiful. and sounded great. but that makes me hate it more… that there was a lot of stuff there that dead ended. i don’t get as worked up when something is completely useless

Expand full comment

Why is Kaia constantly getting papped in front of her DKNY ad? Girl, we know.

Expand full comment
author

she should date leo

Expand full comment